James and the Maidens were pretty pumped to attend this year's pillow fight downtown. I hated to tell him that the event
as cool when it
started, but is a victim of its own success and is now too popular with the bridge & tunnel wannabes to be cool. Shilpa nailed it when she said that "When you see losers boarding BART in
Fremont to go to the pillow fight, it's jumped the shark." Of course we sound snotty, but we're also right. (Not to diminish the fun had by J and the M's.)
The newspaper and various blogs are reporting on a
story that the City wants to crack down on such flash mob socially silly chaotic/anarchic events. Thankfully,
Laughing Squid has a little more on the issue and does correct the (and I use the term loosely) author that these are not flash mobs, and Laughing Squid has nothing to do with them beyond reporting as other blogs and outlets do.
The City has, and I think unfortunately, cracked down on the Urban Iditerod, the Bernal Heights Soapbox Derby, and the Bring Your Own Big Wheel events. Small, citizen-driven fun should be allowed to prosper and flourish as part of the life of this City.
However, I also agree that the scale (3,000 plus people, and it ran for six hours) and the cost of the damage done to public and private property (tens of thousands) by this year's pillow fight is inexcusable. Don't organize and advertise an event, hoping for such scale, if you're not going to take responsibility for it.
Flashmobs are necessarily small and clique-y. They are not so much mobs as flash gatherings. The Zombie crowds don't do any damage (brain or otherwise) other than to willing participants. I say let the ringleaders like Herbie Hatman flourish. The Hide & Seek in the Legion of Honor was respectable and one of my
fondest memories. His shaving foam on paper plates Pie Fight at the cable car turnaround brought fun and soap to a fairly dirty corner-- what could be easier to clean up than soap? The nightly hosing should have taken care of it and likely layers of filth as well.
Small scenes of absurdity are the spirit of San Francisco. But if you're going big scale with absolutely certain security and damage/clean up issues, get the permit or pick up after yourself. We are the life of the City. We citizens should be childish enough to treat our City like a playground
and put our toys away when were done.
Or in other terms, when one scene is over, strike the set for the next act. Let's behave ourselves and keep the grown-ups out of this.